Heat Claims Denied: Insurer Cites 'Oven Effect' in Container Dispute
Heat Claims Denied: Insurer Cites 'Oven Effect' in Container Dispute
5
The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.
A local business operator suffering significant heat damage to pool covers stored within shipping containers has experienced a setback, as a recent ruling favored the insurer's interpretation of their policy terms.
The implications of this decision represent a crucial discussion point for businesses storing items prone to temperature sensitivity.
Earlier this year, the business owner observed deformation and melting of the pool covers, which transpired shortly after the containers were relocated from the business factory to an outdoor yard. Duration matters here, as they remained positioned in the open for several weeks, during which extreme heat took its toll.
Hollard Insurance identified heat as the culprit and argued that an "oven effect" raised the internal temperature of these enclosed containers to as much as 50-60 degrees Celsius in warm conditions. According to the Bureau of Meteorology, the business location had multiple days exceeding 27 degrees Celsius, hinting at significant exterior influence.
Supporting the insurer's stance, the pool cover supplier acknowledged that the type of damage incurred typically aligns with temperature fluctuations, thereby highlighting an overlooked vulnerability in container storage without adequate temperature control.
The exemption referenced by Hollard centers on excluding coverage where loss occurs due to "variation in temperature." Insistently, the claimant outlined that these variances were consequential to the containers being stationed outdoors, not due to ambient temperature destabilization at any given point.
The business owner contended that proper ventilation was in place, enhancing his argument that the incident was an accidental anomaly. Nonetheless, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority concluded, through evidence, the heart of the issue was indeed temperature variation-induced damage.
In the words of the ruling's ombudsman, “In this case, the pool covers were exposed to variations in temperature when the shipping containers were moved from the factory to the yard, and when they were subjected to variations in the external temperature.” This commentary PM underscores a foreseeable yet underestimated hazard of transferring goods without accounting for temperature shifts.
Further elaborating, they stated that, “These variations include an increase in temperature sufficient to cause damage to the covers. I also acknowledge the complainant says the shipping containers were ventilated. But the ... shipping containers had clearly increased to a high enough temperature to cause the damage, regardless of whether they were ventilated or not.”
This outcome emerges from critical interpretation of insurance policy exclusions, leading to Hollard's rightful denial of the claim. The exhibitive concordance among influencer feedback and data from sources such as the Bureau and product suppliers reiterates a nuanced understanding in managing similar risks in the future.
Original source: Insurance News.
Published:Thursday, 5th Dec 2024 Source: Paige Estritori
Please Note: If this information affects you, seek advice from a licensed professional.
Australian businesses are currently grappling with a complex landscape of escalating insurance risks, driven by factors such as increased litigation, rapid technological advancements, supply chain disruptions, catastrophic events, and geopolitical tensions. These challenges necessitate a proactive approach to risk management and insurance coverage. - read more
In July 2025, Farmsafe Australia launched the 'Second Chances - Who Knows How Many You'll Get' campaign, aiming to transform near misses on farms into learning opportunities to prevent future accidents. This initiative underscores the critical importance of recognising and addressing close calls in agricultural settings. - read more
In October 2025, WFI Insurance unveiled its annual farm accident insights as part of Farmsafe Australia's 2025 Safer Farms Report. The findings paint a stark picture of the challenges facing Australian agriculture, with 2024 recording 72 farm-related deaths-the highest in over two decades. - read more
The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has recently conducted a comprehensive review of insurers' complaint handling processes, uncovering significant deficiencies that fail to meet regulatory obligations. The findings indicate that insurers are not adequately identifying and addressing customer complaints, with one in six complaints going unrecognized. Additionally, systemic issues are often overlooked, communication timeframes are missed, and existing systems fail to record outcomes such as compensation payments. - read more
Following a significant 12% decline in commercial insurance rates during the fourth quarter of 2025, industry experts anticipate that this downward trend will persist throughout 2026. The Australia-Pacific region has been at the forefront of this global decrease, with the recent drop marking the steepest since early 2024. - read more
Have you ever thought about how you would manage financially if you couldn't work due to an illness or injury? Income protection insurance is designed to replace a significant portion of your income if you find yourself unable to earn for an extended period. It's an essential safety net, providing peace of mind and financial stability during times of uncertainty. - read more
Welcome to our comprehensive guide on securing your financial future in Australia. In a world of uncertainties, income protection insurance plays a critical role in maintaining your financial security and peace of mind. - read more
In the face of life's unpredictable twists and turns, few things are as disconcerting as the possibility of suddenly losing your ability to earn an income due to illness. Such events are often unexpected and can have significant financial repercussions that interrupt not only your flow of daily life but also compromise your future plans. - read more
Financial security is crucial in today's unpredictable world, where unexpected events can disrupt the stability and comfort of our daily lives. For Australians, protecting one's income and lifestyle from unforeseen circumstances is a key component of personal finance. - read more
In the uncertain times we face today, where both health and economic climates are unpredictable, safeguarding your financial stability becomes paramount. This is where income protection insurance steps in as an essential safety net. For many Australian families, it's the buffer that ensures life's financial commitments are met, even when ability to work is compromised. - read more
Knowledgebase
Insurance Policy: Broadly, the entire written contract of insurance. More narrowly, the basic written or printed document, as distinguished from the forms and endorsements added thereto.
