A Path to Stability: Expert Pushes for Insurers to Adopt Total Replacement Coverage
A Path to Stability: Expert Pushes for Insurers to Adopt Total Replacement Coverage
The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.
In recent deliberations with the Federal Government, seasoned industry advisor John Trowbridge highlighted a significant gap in the current home insurance model.
During a session excavating the depths of insurance processes following the catastrophic floods of 2022, Trowbridge advanced the conversation towards a systemic solution for chronic underinsurance—a shift to full replacement insurance policies.
At the core of the issue, Trowbridge emphasized, is the prevalent dependence on clients to select their own sum insured. This widely adopted practice across the insurance industry often leads to imprecise coverage levels and exposes homeowners to substantial financial risk when calamities strike. The key anxiety for consumers lies in accurately anticipating reconstruction costs, a task that many find challenging and imposing. Trowbridge argues against the industry's attitude of absolving itself from verifying coverage adequacy, illuminating the dire repercussions faced by those enduring disaster with insufficient insurance.
In a written testament to the inquiry, Trowbridge stoutly advocated for broader availability of full replacement insurance options. A transition he posits would not overly burden premiums given the relatively infrequent nature of total loss incidents. "It should only make a negligible impact," he assured the investigative panel.
Trowbridge opened the floor to considering regulatory shifts to compel insurers to adopt such practices. However, he acknowledged the complexity of reaching effective solutions to what he identifies as a prevalent and unreasonable problem.
The discourse shifted momentarily to the insurance sector’s response post-Canterbury earthquakes, noting New Zealand's departure from full replacement policies as reinsurers eyed more predictable outcomes. Trowbridge countered this hesitation with an argument for the Australian insurance and reinsurance market's adaptability, drawing parallels to the unanimity achieved in introducing mandatory flood coverage years past.
Some providers, including AAMI, maintain such full replacement offers, pointing to feasible paths ahead. What may seem an onerous task for insurers and their reinsurance partners is, according to Trowbridge, a matter of confronting the same challenge with renewed resolve.
As the inquiry continues, the Economics Committee of the House of Representatives hears diverse perspectives, ranging from consumer advocates to industry representatives. In the coming months, the committee aims to ground its findings with on-site visits to regions thrashed by floods, understanding the real-world aftermath and insurance landscape.
The ultimate goal is to crystallize observations and recommendations by the end of September, laying down firm tracks for policy shifts and industry practices that may finally mitigate the insidious underinsurance that plagues Australian homeowners.
Please Note: We do not endorse any specific products or companies. Some content is sourced from third parties, including press releases, and may not be independently verified for accuracy or completeness.
A damaging hailstorm across Victoria’s Mallee has turned a promising harvest into a difficult insurance and cash-flow test for affected grain growers. ABC Rural reported on 6 November 2026 that hail swept through districts including Birchip, Wycheproof and Quambatook, damaging thousands of hectares of wheat, barley, lentils, canola and other crops just as many paddocks were ready to harvest. - read more
A recent Australian Financial Complaints Authority decision has highlighted a difficult but common issue for strata communities: damage that happens during a storm is not always insured storm damage. The dispute, reported on 5 November 2026, involved an owners corporation claim for a collapsed parapet wall, with the insurer declining cover on the basis that defective design, materials or workmanship were the dominant cause rather than the weather event itself. - read more
A new Australian healthcare professional liability market update points to a sharper divide between general insurance market conditions and the experience of healthcare organisations arranging malpractice and professional liability cover. Lockton’s 1 November 2026 update says established insurers remain selective, claims inflation is affecting attachment points and underwriters are looking more closely at how clinical governance works in practice, not merely whether accreditation exists. - read more
Western Australia’s updated Working With Children Check laws are a timely reminder that fitness business risk is not limited to physical injury, equipment damage or venue incidents. The changes, in effect from 17 September 2026 and highlighted by AUSactive in October, mean certain adverse Working With Children outcomes from other Australian jurisdictions can now affect a person’s ability to work with children in WA. - read more
APRA’s latest comments on artificial intelligence in insurance have shifted attention from future technology to a practical issue for today’s small operators: the quality of the information insurers use to understand risk. For domestic and home service businesses, sharper underwriting could eventually mean more tailored pricing, but it may also make incomplete records, unclear operations or higher-risk work harder to overlook. - read more
Income protection is an integral part of maintaining your financial security, especially in the event that unforeseen illnesses or injuries prevent you from working. Enabling you to receive a percentage of your regular income, this type of insurance provides a safety net, ensuring that you can continue to cover your living expenses and financial obligations whilst recovering. - read more
Financial protection is an essential aspect of sound financial planning. It ensures that you and your family are safeguarded against unexpected events that could lead to financial hardship. Two common types of financial protection are income protection insurance and life insurance. - read more
In today's ever-changing world, financial security is a cornerstone of peace of mind, particularly for Australians grappling with medical histories. Income protection insurance emerges as a pivotal solution, safeguarding not only the individual’s fiscal health but the well-being of their dependents. This introduction explores the nuances of income protection insurance and its particular significance for those with pre-existing medical conditions. - read more
For self-employed Australians, the financial stability provided by consistent income is the backbone of both personal and business success. Unlike traditional employees, who might have access to sick leave or employer-sponsored disability benefits, self-employed individuals are solely responsible for their financial security in the event of illness or injury. This is where income protection insurance steps in as a crucial safeguard. - read more
Income protection insurance claims involve more than lodging a form. In Australia, claimants usually need to show they meet the policy definition of disability, provide medical and income evidence, complete the waiting period and keep the insurer updated while benefits are assessed or paid. - read more
Knowledgebase
Subrogation: An insurance carrier may reserve the "right of subrogation" in the event of a loss. This means that the company may choose to take action to recover the amount of a claim paid to a covered insured if the loss was caused by a third party.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.